Fatty'z Pizza

Great pizza, great service. absolutely love the place.

So good! And such a great value.

The best pizza that I had since I left my home state Wisconsin.

Well... I'm from NY and I have to say by far it's the best pizza I've had on the west coast.

Thanks, we love your pizza!!! Last week my son had a school project about important places in your community. He picked your pizzaria! Here is a picture of the project.

First time ordering delivery from Fatty's. Got pizza, wings, and a salad. Wow. I'm an east coast guy and the pizza was great. Crust was phenomenal. We ordered both buffalo style and garlic parm style wings, and were not disappointed. Delivery was easy with a card reader at the door. We'll definitely be ordering from Fatty's again. Good food, great value. We'll

Great tasting pizza at affordable prices

Huge, DeLuxe, Freshly Made Pizza!!

Our first time eating there. The pizza was really good. We had the lunch combo with meat lovers, the islander, and chicken bacon ranch. The Islander was our favorite. Comes with a drink and there are free refills. Great customer service!

Great for lunch and good price

Love their food! Great menu to choose from. Outstanding service and friendly employees. Great place, my grandson's also enjoy eating here when they are in town!

Excellent NY style pizza!

Just found out about Fatty's. OMG!!! Excellent 👍 New York, thin crust pizza. Absolutely fantastic, I'll be back soon.

Pizza was awesome was a great lunch love how you Can buy A slice of pizza

This pizza is really good. You can call in or do delivery but I think best value has got to be their slice and drink prices.

Just really good pizza

Hands down best pizza place in Mountain Home!

Excellent New York style pizza. People were very nice, pizza had a clean fresh taste, highly recommend.

Hands down, the best pizza in town. They make pizza the way it should be made.

Out of Towner here, love looking for good local fare. Great NY style, hand tossed pizza. Super tasty garlic knots, love their sauce! We had the Meateot, perfect blend of toppings for great flavor in every bite. GREAT Prices, meticulously clean place, with friendly staff. Give it a try!!!

Good Pizza, Great Service. Always a good stop when I'm in MH.

My dad likes to take me to Fatty's and I've always loved it there. Their staff is nice and bathroom is clean. All ingredients are fresh. I love the greasy pizza more than any other food. Can't wait till I go back! Keep up the good work!!! 🤣👍

Showed up 20 mins before closing time to get a pizza after a long days work and saw that the chairs were all put up from outside the restaurant so I called to ask if it was too late to order a pizza for pickup, from outside, and they told me "we are all booked up for the night" an obvious lie as they were clearly empty and closing but simply didnt want to help a late night customer.

This place is good the owner is out making deliverys cool dude all ingredients where fresh love the food

Closest to NY Pizza I have found in Idaho so far

The best pizza you are going to find for miles!

Fantastic pizza. For sure one if my favorites. At a great price too!

Best place in town, real New York style pizza, friendly service and great music playing!

Good, gigantic slices of pizza pie! Better have some napkins handy because a slice of this pepperoni pizza could rival those on the streets of NYC in terms of greasy goodness. Okay, while it's not NYC pizza, it is good. I vividly remember the size of the pizza boxes when our office would order from Fatty'z!

Eric and Kyle are really cool. Pizza and garlic knots are delicious. Jalapeno ranch is awesome.

Great pizza... Thanks.

The pizza is great. If your looking for a quick bite. Its also a relaxed atmosphere where if yoir looking to pick up u can grab a beer while you wait. Great service and delicious fresh made pizza

Great pizza with great prices.

Took an hour and 30 minutes to deliver our food, ordered a two litter Pepsi and was brought two 1 liter sprites instead, ordered garlic bread and got some hard dough with chunks of minced garlic thrown on top. Pizza was tasteless, super greasy, and the crust was as hard as the garlic dough. I don’t want to even give them a star because they honestly suck! Anybody who says this place is good clearly has never had a decent pizza in their life!

Premium Pizza No More!!! What once was a pizza to look forward to. One that seemed to be made with love and consideration ya not holding that flame. Consistently I am presented with “greasy mediocrity” Up and Over; Time and Time Again A lack of consistent quality, is this chance worth gambling the 20 or so dollars for my great mistake “I literally am writing this waking up; late at night after I couldn’t eat more than one piece of this mess, and woke up with sour gut!! burbing like, we’ll you know 🤫 not severer, but it is what it is 🤢” all in all I’d re omens next time getting the single piece in the day time if I feel like ever rolling the dice in the future again.. 🍕 📷 #Gamblelunch

Health concerns for food handlingFood didn't taste good

Best pizza in Mountain Home! No competition! Always friendly staff, deliver locally... Not much more to say except THANK YOU!

My husband and I LOVE, LOVE LOVE Fatty's pizza. We👍 lways order an extra large so we'll have leftovers. 😁 I'm kinda bummed though. It's 11:15 a.m. and no one's answering the phone. Just figured out why. Your info on Google says you open at 11a.m. I just tried to order a pizza for delivery and it says you're not open till 2p.m. 🙃 Maybe you should update your Google site.

Honestly was a bit skeptical when I first walked in. But after I tasted the pizza I was hooked. It's close to New York tasting pizza you can get with out actually going to New York. "Nothing compares to New York pizza" but none the less its food pizza. Staff wasn't bad and they offered a military discount.

Loved the pizza! Family friendly.

I love Fatty'z pizza! I love the fact they deliver! I'm horribly upset at the way the delivery drivers drive through our Subdivision. Almost got hit yesterday on Silverstone St.

Great service, large slices, good flavors.

This is the best pizza for 500 miles. I'm from the east coast and a good pizza is extremely hard to find and this is the best I could find.

Oh my MG this pizza was amazing. The crust done perfectly.. the ingredients so fresh. Service was spot on! From Las Vegas which has great pizza places. This was my favorite! What a wonderful surprise! Awesome!!

First time there, had two slices of their ham and sausage, crust was perfectly crispy, cheese was nice and stringy, and I recommend trying the jalapeno ranch

Great pizza. Nice location across from the park. Good view also.

Great local pizza at a fair price. No WiFi but not a deal breaker. Worth the trip.

New York style pizza! So far, this is the only place who sells pizza I can like. Bf and I come from east coast and have extensive knowledge of pizza. Fresh dough, rolled in corn flour, italian pizza sauce, finest cheeses, big pepperoni, and low prices. Great salads, wings, knots, and drinks. Fatty's is our go to here in Mountain Home! Actually checked to make sure they had a pizza joint before we moved here. Check for specials daily and military discount offered a plus.

This place is absolutely terrible , I ordered pizza , cinnamon bread, and garlic bread and they all came out horrific . They were all old and I will never order from this place again . Save your money

Yall don't even know... This place is hella delicious, friendly, aaaaaand they have a little killer IPA THAT IS BOMB!! I got a bit of everything. Garden salad (so much cheese I almost cried with delight), veggie pie, and wings (a little on the small side but great). All great!!! And they are still open with the construction.